The music industry is taking a strong stand against Artificial Intelligence (AI) song generator apps, Suno and Udio, accusing them of copyright infringement. Leading record labels, including Universal Music Group, Sony Music Entertainment, and Warner Music Group, have filed lawsuits to protect their intellectual property rights.
BACKGROUND
AI technology is rapidly advancing, deepening its roots in human lives, enabling the creation of anything from Poems and articles to song and movies through sophisticated algorithms and use of AI technology such as Machine Learning and Natural Language Processing. Application such as SUNO and UDIO AI songs generating AI application that can produce a song simply by writing your imagination. With their objective of “From Mind to Music”, these AI song generators can produce music that closely mimics the styles of well-known artists.
THE LAWSUIT
The lawsuits are filed by top music labels in both the United States and Europe, alleging that Suno and Udio have used copyrighted material of their artists without any prior consent to train their AI models. One case is filed in Boston in USA against SunoAI and the other in NewYork against Unchartered Labs, the creator of UdioAI. The record labels argue that this constitutes copyright infringement and seeks damages for the unauthorized use of their songs. The plaintiffs are pushing for significant financial compensation of upto 150,000 Dollars, and an injunction to stop the AI companies from using their copyrighted material.
STATEMENTS FROM THE REPRESENTATIVES
Following the filing of the lawsuits, Representatives from the record labels have emphasized the importance of protecting artists’ rights and ensuring that they should be fairly compensated for their work. “The unauthorized use of our artist’s music by these AI companies is unacceptable. We are committed to defending the rights of our artists and the integrity of their creative work”, said a spokesperson from Universal Music Group.
RIAA’s chairman and chief executive, Mitch Glazier has also defended the rights of artists made a written statement that they are collaborating with AI developers for responsible use of the capabilities of AI in music industry, but “unlicensed services like Suno and Udio that claim it’s ‘fair’ to copy an artist’s life’s work and exploit it for their own profit without consent or pay set back the promise of genuinely innovative AI for us all”.
On the other hand, Suno and Udio have defended their practices, arguing that their use of copyrighted material falls under fair use. Whereas Udio haven’t said anything about the ongoing case yet, SunoAI has claimed that their AI-generated songs are transformative works that do not directly copy the original material. “Our technology is designed to inspire new creativity, not to infringe on existing copyrights”, said a representative from Udio.
IMPACT ON MUSIC INDUSTRY
The outcome of these lawsuits could have far-reaching implications for the music industry and AI technology. A ruling in favor of the record labels could establish precedent for future cases, potentially limiting the capabilities of AI in music production. It could also lead to stricter regulations on how AI models are trained and the use of copyrighted material in the process.
It is note worthy that in the month of April over 200 artists have signed an open letter with the Artists Rights Alliance Non-Profit calling out AI developers, for using their copyrighted work saying, “to infringe upon and devalue the rights of human artists”.
Link to the complaint filed against SUNO AI is available here.
Link to the complaint filed against Udio AI is available here.
References: